S&S Cinchy Ceviche

One “S” is for scallops, the other is for snapper. But it could be for simple or Sayulita or sunny or spicy. All of those words apply here.

About a month ago, I headed up to Seattle for the weekend to visit friends. (Seattle! Another “S” word that works here. Ooooh, snap!) On a warm Friday night, we celebrated Britt’s birthday in their big backyard. Andrew made carnitas and ice cream sandwiches and Britt made a big bowl of ceviche. We ate and played corn hole and drank wine. I was the friend hovering over the ceviche bowl, scooping bites onto tortilla chips with one hand and holding up the other to catch the salty, lime juice drips. It was so fresh with tart lime and tender fish, I couldn’t get enough of it.

Fast forward a couple of weeks and I’m in sunny Sayulita, Mexico with my dear friend Pea. We took a spontaneous leap and headed down there for Labor Day weekend. I was eager to try the ceviche. We bought a couple plates at a little roadside stall, but the fish had been pulverized to the consistency of couscous. I didn’t understand it. It was no bueno.

We stuck to taco eating at a little spot called Bichos (yes, that means Bugs en Espanol). They were the best tacos ever, made with freshly-pressed, corn tortillas hot from the pan. I could happily eat them everyday for the rest of my life. We filled our days with stand-up paddleboarding, book reading, tropical fruit eating, beach walking, hill exploring, and Spanglish speaking. We filled our nights with margarita drinking and taco eating. It was the vacation to end all vacations. The only thing not satisfied upon leaving was my ceviche craving.

Fortunately, Britt kindly shared her ceviche-making process with me. No recipe, just notes. It is truly cinchy.  Yesterday afternoon, Elle and I whipped up a batch for a Sunday evening picnic with Patrick in Dolores Park. It makes excellent picnic food when among friends who don’t mind all the double-dipping of tortilla chips. We served the ceviche with homemade guacamole, chips, good salsa, crispy chickpeas, and Dr. Bradley’s pureed plum cocktail with tequila and mint. Very bueno.

I encourage you to improvise with ingredients, keeping in mind that very fresh, de-boned seafood and plenty of fresh lime juice are your anchors on this S&S ceviche ship of dreams. 

Cinchy Ceviche with Scallops and Snapper

Serves 6

1 1/2 pounds very fresh, firm seafood, cut into bite-sized pieces  (I used a mix of scallops, snapper and tilapia. Raw shrimp would work well too.)

juice of 5 limes

small bunch of radishes, rinsed and sliced into very thin rounds

5-7 ripe tomatoes, cut into bite-sized chunks

1/2 red onion, chopped

large handful of fresh cilantro, stems removed and chopped

1-3 Thai bird chilies, seeds removed and finely minced

coarse sea salt and fresh pepper, to taste


Put raw seafood in a large, glass (non-reactive) bowl, sprinkle generously with sea salt and cover with lime juice. Cover and chill for about 45 minutes, allowing the lime juice to cook the fish and turn it white.

Gently mix in the red onion, tomatoes, chilies, radish and cilantro. Season with salt and pepper as needed.
Chill and serve with tortilla chips and fresh guacamole. Or, Britt served her ceviche with a side of popped corn nuts. The salty and crunchy complements the fresh and sour perfectly.

4 thoughts on “S&S Cinchy Ceviche

  1. Annie! I’m going to Sayulita in November–we should touch base before then so I can get your advice on what to see/do. And the ceviche looks amazing:)

  2. This is wonderful. Great recipe, great photos, great text. When the ship comes into Bozeman, we will be all over this. XOXOXOXOX Pom and Hen

  3. One more thing–How about posting the recipe for Dr. Bradley’s Plum Cocktail? Wine is fine but a cocktail can start things shaking. XOX

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s